Skip to main content

How do you replace a cracked PSA, SGC or BGS slab?

Learn when a cracked slab needs a reholder, compare dated PSA and SGC fees, and document damage before arranging a safe return or submission.

Published
Last reviewed
Reading time
5 minutes

The short answer

A cracked slab should stay closed while you photograph the damage and contact the grading company. Reholder eligibility depends on the holder and card condition. PSA and SGC publish different services and value limits; a broken seal or crack near the card can require a new examination rather than a routine holder replacement.
  • Photograph the whole slab, crack, label and packaging before doing anything.
  • A reholder is not a guaranteed preservation of the old grade.
  • Add both shipping legs to the service fee; confirm current BGS availability directly.

First decide whether this is a delivery problem or a submission

For an incorrect CGC label or a suspected encapsulation mistake, separate a correction request from later holder damage. The linked guide explains the current return window and evidence to keep.

If the slab arrived damaged, preserve the shipping box, padding, label and listing photographs. Start with the seller or platform’s damage process before paying another company to change the evidence. Note when you received it and when you first noticed the crack. A photograph of the empty box alone does not show what happened to the slab.

For a slab already in your collection, set it on a clean, stable surface and photograph both faces plus the damaged edge. Avoid flexing it to see how far the crack travels. Record whether the card appears to touch the damaged area, but do not push the plastic or probe the seam. These observations help support staff route the item.

CGC mechanical-error return guide

Use a crack-location decision flow

The following is an original triage aid, not a grading-company diagnosis. A superficial scuff, an edge chip and a fracture across the card window are different problems. Pictures cannot prove that a seal is intact, so describe what you can see instead of declaring the holder safe.

What to record before requesting service
ObservationPractical next stepWhat remains uncertain
Surface scuff; no visible openingAsk about ordinary reholder eligibilityWhether plastic or card is affected
Corner chip away from cardSend close and wide photographsInternal damage or loss of seal integrity
Crack over the card; loose fragmentStop handling and obtain specific instructionsCard damage and whether regrading is required
Opened seam or card removedDisclose the opening and ask for grading instructionsPrevious grade cannot be assumed to carry forward

Compare the correct reholder fee

PSA and Beckett fees were rechecked October 30, 2026. SGC remains an October 19 snapshot because its current source could not be read; confirm it before paying. These prices cover only the stated formats and values. They exclude shipping and additional charges. Do not select the cheapest line until the company confirms that the damaged holder qualifies.

Published reholder examples; PSA/BGS October 30, SGC October 19
Company and routeService feePublished value boundaryEstimate
PSA Standard Reholder$12.99Maximum insured value $2,00080–90 business days
PSA standard, tallboy and jumbo$29.99Maximum insured value $5,00065–75 business days
SGC standard-size Standard reholder$50Maximum declared value $3,50040+ business days
SGC same bracket, Expedited$100Maximum declared value $3,5002–3 business days
BGS recaseFrom $9.95 per card (BGS only)Ask Beckett with card and damage detailsConfirm directly

Understand what could happen to the grade

PSA generally keeps the grade and certification number for eligible reholders, but inspects the holder, label and card circumstances. Its terms specifically address fractures near the item, opened holders and changed condition. SGC states that an opened holder requires regrading. Those rules are why opening the case yourself is not a harmless way to speed up a reholder.

Keep your original photos and the company’s response with the order. If preservation of the existing grade matters more than a newer case, explain that before shipping and ask what outcomes are possible. A service name does not override the inspection requirements.

Work out the entire cost before buying a damaged slab

Illustrative example: a card in a damaged holder costs $90, a qualifying PSA reholder costs $12.99, and your assumed inbound and return shipping are $10 and $20. The total is $132.99 before taxes, supplies or any additional examination. A clean already-holdered copy offered for $125 may therefore cost less, even though its sticker price is higher.

This comparison assumes the damaged card qualifies for that tier. It assigns no value to waiting, service risk or your time. If the quote changes or the card cannot retain its previous grade, rerun the comparison rather than treating the first estimate as a ceiling.

Prepare the support request and shipment

Give the company the certification number, card identity, approximate value, photos and a plain description of when the damage appeared. Ask which service and holder format to select. Beckett’s live grading page checked October 30 lists Recase (BGS only) from $9.95 per card and Relabel separately from $9.95. A label correction and a damaged case are different jobs. The starting fee does not establish eligibility, turnaround or the final shipped total; request the appropriate quote before sending your card.

After receiving instructions, protect the entire slab against movement and impact. Do not remove the card or apply glue to the case. Retain the packing photographs, tracking receipt and a copy of the submitted inventory. On return, compare the card, label and certification record with your earlier documentation.

Frequently asked questions

Does a reholder automatically raise the grade?

No. Replacing a holder is different from requesting a grade review. Choose the service for the actual problem and confirm whether damage changes the required examination.

Can a cracked PSA slab keep its grade?

Sometimes, but it depends on inspection. Cracks near the card, evidence of opening or changed card condition can prevent routine reholder treatment.

What is the current SGC reholder fee?

The standard-size table checked October 19, 2026 lists $50 Standard up to $3,500 declared value, or $100 Expedited in that bracket. Shipping is separate.

Should I crack the card out first?

Keep it in the existing holder while asking for instructions. Removing it destroys the original sealed-holder context and can change the service and grading outcome.

How much does a BGS recase cost?

Beckett’s live grading page lists Recase (BGS only) from $9.95 per card as checked October 30, 2026. Confirm damaged-holder eligibility, timing, shipping and any extra charges; the starting fee is not the final order total.

Can I sell it before repair?

If you sell a damaged holder, describe and photograph the damage accurately. Do not present the future reholder result or preservation of the grade as guaranteed.

Sources

Product checklists, definitions, and policies can change. These sources were reviewed on 2026-10-19.

  1. PSA ReholderFees, value limits, estimates and required inspection rechecked October 30, 2026.
  2. PSA submission termsDamaged or opened holders and reholder exceptions.
  3. SGC services and pricingRendered Reholders tab checked October 19, 2026: $50/$100 bracket up to $3,500 and opened-holder regrading rule.
  4. Beckett live grading and additional servicesOctober 30: Recase (BGS only) from $9.95, Relabel separately from $9.95. Confirm eligibility and final quote.

Card Collector Capital publishes educational research, not financial advice. Card prices, populations, checklists, and grading policies can change. Verify the exact card and current information before buying, selling, or submitting a card.